The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has imposed a penalty of Rs35 million on Sarina Isa, wife of Supreme Court Judge Qazi Faez Isa, in a case related to disclosure of foreign properties.
Sources told The Express Tribune on Friday that the FBR has ruled that Sarina is liable to pay tax liabilities of Rs35 million over non-disclosure of three properties in the United Kingdom.
Under the Supreme Court June 19 order, Sarina may avail all legal options against the FBR order.
Raising doubts over the 164-page order issued on September 14, Sarina accused FBR official Zulfiqar Ahmed of creating “artificial tax liability of over Rs35 million” against her.
“I don’t even know if he wrote the order himself,” she said in her written response vowing to challenge the FBR verdict.
She termed the FBR’s verdict “a piece of fiction”, saying the ruling was issued without hearing her and the FBR official “condemned her unheard”.
Last month, Sarina Isa had disputed the FBR assessment about her income as well as the value of her foreign properties.
"You finally accept that I was a working woman but then qualify it by saying that I only had taxed source only to the tune of Rs9,375,931. You have also determined the purchase of three properties at Rs104,680,020.
“I do not know where you have taken the figure of Rs9,375,931 from as you do not provide the details nor [tell] how you have determined the amount of Rs104,680,020. Please do so now," Sarina said in her written reply to the FRB’s fourth notice issued on August 21. The reply was submitted last week of August.
A 10-judge bench of the Supreme Court on June 19 quashed a presidential reference which claimed that Justice Isa – who is in line to become the chief justice of Pakistan – had committed misconduct by not disclosing his family member’s foreign properties in his wealth statement.
In the split order, the bench had, however, asked the FBR to launch an inquiry into the foreign properties of the judge’s family members and to submit its report to the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) – the constitutional forum that can hold a superior court judge accountable.
Responding to the FBR’s notice, Sarina had once again requested it to provide the documents which were relied on in assessment. Likewise, she also sought a copy of all her returns. Sarina said she had started to work in Karachi American School 38 years ago – before her marriage – and worked there for decades.
“I do not know from which date you started [reckoning] my earning. Is it the date from which I started working at the school or when I started to submit my own returns?
“I also do not know whether you added the non-taxable part of my earnings in my earnings. Please answer my questions and provide copies of tax filing of the school and copies of all my returns."
Sarina said she along with a friend bought an office in the Clifton area of Karachi which was later rented. However, income tax is not payable on a certain percentage of amount from the rent. She asked the FBR as to whether it examined this aspect.
Sarina said she later sold that office at a profit. "Have you taken the sale consideration into account and treated it as part of my savings?" she asked.
She said she also purchased a house at Clifton which was also rented out. The rent income was disclosed and tax also paid after permissible deductions. She asked as to whether certain percentages of deductions were considered as her earnings.
She stated that she also sold out that house later at profit and there was no requirement of paying on capital gains. Have you taken sale into account, she asked.
Sarina also revealed that she owned 278 acres of land – which is equal to 2,243 kanals.
This land was managed by her father who died on June 25 this year. However, due to shortage of time, she could not give the exact amount which she earned from agricultural land.
She said the amount of agricultural income would easily cover the price of the three properties prior to dates that they were bought. Once I visit Jacobabad and Nasirabad then I will be able to provide you information about earning from these lands, she added.
Sarina stated that she invested income from the agricultural land in saving certificates issued by the government of Pakistan. Some of the agricultural income was deposited in a rupees account in UBL.
She said her agricultural income is sufficient to justify purchase of three properties in the UK.
"The price of the UK pounds and the USA dollars was less than they were bought. I do not accept as alleged by you that the price of properties was Rs104,680,020. Where have you taken the figure from."
KARACHI: Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) lawmaker Khurrum Sher Zaman on Monday said the [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD: Proclamations for summoning convicted former premier Nawaz Sharif in the Ave [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD: Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, Leader of Hezb-e-Islami of Afghanistan, along with a de [ ... ]
Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) Vice President Maryam Nawaz said her husband and PML [ ... ]
Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, leader of Hezb-e-Islami of Afghanistan, along with a delegation arri [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD: The top court has declared that grant of bail to an accused is not an “ir [ ... ]
PESHAWAR: Hours after the arrest of former prime minister Nawaz Sharif’s son-in-law C [ ... ]
Opposition leaders in Karachi as Pakistan Democratic Movement's public gathering ge [ ... ]
Told @FareedZakaria on GPS @CNN, America’s failure on COVID-19 is almost unimaginable [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD/ KARACHI: A day after the minister for railways accused three-time former pri [ ... ]
“I saw my father being verbally abusive throughout my childhood and my mother simply j [ ... ]
Opposition leaders in Karachi as Pakistan Democratic Movement's public gathering ge [ ... ]
BEIJING: Pakistani students showcased their talent and won prizes in the speech, photog [ ... ]
PPP workers at Bagh-e-Jinnah rally. PHOTO: EXPRESS
MULTAN: Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi said on Sunday that he firmly believed th [ ... ]
I extend warmest felicitations to @presidentaz & fraternal people of #Azerbaijan on [ ... ]
KARACHI: With the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) all set to stage a rally to mark the 13t [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD: Ehsaas hosted a high-level virtual event to commemorate the World Poverty Da [ ... ]
RAWALPINDI: Minister for Aviation Ghulam Sarwar Khan on Saturday said that the governme [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD: The Auditor General of Pakistan has revealed that the Ministry of Law and J [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD: American blogger Cynthia Dawn Ritchie on Saturday challenged in the Islamaba [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) on Saturday issued a three-page written orde [ ... ]
KARACHI: The Federal Investigation Authority's (FIA) Corporate Crime Circle arrested fo [ ... ]
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan told India on Saturday to reflect on its own egregious behaviour ma [ ... ]
Warmest congratulations to @jacindaarden on her impressive victory in #NZelections2020. [ ... ]
LONDON: Andy Murray has suffered another injury setback and has pulled out of this week [ ... ]
MADRID: Suzuki's Alex Rins held off a spirited challenge from Repsol Honda rookie Alex [ ... ]
LONDON: Russian third seed Andrey Rublev won his fourth ATP Tour title of the year when [ ... ]
LONDON: Liverpool have been a dealt a huge blow with news that centre back Virgil van D [ ... ]
LONDON: When Gareth Bale came off the bench in the 72nd minute to begin his second chap [ ... ]
LONDON: Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola says Sergio Aguero can still play an impo [ ... ]
LONDON: Talking points from the Premier League weekend: VAN DIJK INJURY BLOWS HOLE IN L [ ... ]
LONDON: Aston Villa stretched their perfect Premier League start to four wins after a s [ ... ]
CANBERRA: Marcus Rashford insists Edinson Cavani will prove a valuable addition for Man [ ... ]
CANBERRA: Gerard Pique called for changes from top to bottom but 65 days have passed si [ ... ]
CANBERRA: Andrea Pirlo takes his first managerial steps in the Champions League at Dyna [ ... ]
CANBERRA: Chelsea's huge transfer spend has so far failed to deliver the expected retur [ ... ]
LONDON: Arsene Wenger has brushed off Jose Mourinho's reaction to being left out of the [ ... ]
The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) is close to finalising venues for the upcoming Test and [ ... ]
MILAN: Juventus coach Andrea Pirlo was left to fret over two more dropped points and th [ ... ]
View this post on Instagram Ever [ ... ]
View this post on Instagram Toda [ ... ]
Bollywood filmmaker Vishal Bhardwaj who is known for adapting Shakesperean tragedies in I [ ... ]
why tf is pakistan making sasta money heist.... pic.twitter.com/xoI7jQtV9N — vase⁷ [ ... ]
C'est la vie, and who would know that better than Aaminah Haq, who has yet again proved h [ ... ]
A bronze statue of Shah Rukh Khan and Kajol will be unveiled at London's Leicester Square [ ... ]
The Oshiwara Police Station has registered a complaint alleging rape charges against vete [ ... ]
View this post on Instagram Whic [ ... ]
Bollywood actor Manoj Bajpayee feels that the star system in the Indian film industry h [ ... ]
NEW YORK: Film theatres outside of New York City will be allowed to reopen on Oct. 23 a [ ... ]
Bollywood veteran Hema Malini has spoken up against the negativity the Indian film indust [ ... ]
Hollywood actor Micheal B. Jordan is working to bring another black superhero to the big [ ... ]
One year on from #RoyalVisitPakistan
View this post on Instagram #can [ ... ]
An official statement from Sony Pictures, the studio behind the Spider-Man films, has d [ ... ]